

cancel culture
currently a buzz-word. a trendy comment.
* a certain loud individual is not being allowed to use certain social media platforms.
{gasp} cancel culture
nothing in the constitution prohibits a private company from enforcing its own policies; if anything, the First Amendment protects a company’s right to do so. social media platforms are owned by private companies. their owners/CEOs/boards get to decide who is allowed to use their platforms.
* an estate decided to look at some of the books they own and not publish some of those any longer.
{gasp} cancel culture
they own the books. they may decide not to publish what they own if they wish. also, nobody has "cancelled" Dr. Seuss. over the last few years, people have brought to our attention the part that Seuss played in anti-Japanese sentiments in this country during WWII, and other negative stereotypes that he advanced in his children's books and political cartoons. i don't believe that we should just tell kids that he was the greatest children's book author; there are so many authors who could be celebrated - many who didn't write horrible stereotypes into their cartoons and stories. this doesn't mean we can't still enjoy the Grinch and other Seuss stories - but Seuss certainly doesn't need to be on a pedestal for the entire month of march.
* no more Mr. tagged to Potato Head.
{gasp} cancel culture
we all know we could make those potatoes be any Mr./Mrs./mashup we wanted to before. who didn't put the big eyelashes with the mustache and the made-up lips with the bushy eyebrows at one time or another when they were a kid? Potato Head is certainly a sufficient name.
* a statue is being taken down.
{gasp} cancel culture
there is a marked difference between saying we won't celebrate and honor those who perpetuated sins against those who are also Americans and actually erasing history. there is also great value in looking at intent - many monuments, statues, etc, were only erected to intimidate during times where progress and growth were becoming a possible reality. i will absolutely NOT celebrate those who participated in enslaving or massacring entire groups of people. this is not the same thing as erasing any part of history - all of this will still be taught in schools and will still be in books and museums and in print and in online articles and archives. but, i think that we all know that some people do not deserve a statue. i recommend you read this article to understand the way the removal of a Columbus statue from the MN State Capitol grounds was handled.
i think that if we truly want to understand cancel culture, we need to meet a Native American neighbor, sit with them, shut our mouths, and listen to how their parents and grandparents were forbidden to speak their own language, forbidden to follow their religion (until 1978. one year before my husband was born. 1978, people. here. in the land of freedom of religion.). listen to how they were forced to remove their clothing; how they were shorn of their hair. listen to how somehow, when horrible things happen to Native American people, there is conveniently no one with the correct jurisdiction to take care of them, to bring justice to an unjust situation. listen. then we might begin to understand cancel culture.
meet a Black neighbor and listen to them tell us how they cannot trace their ancestry, because their ancestors were torn from their homeland, they were raped, they were killed, they were treated as one-fifth of a human being - as if that were better than being treated worse than an animal. listen to how often their neighbors and friends and children are suspended from school or locked up for crimes they didn't commit or sentenced many times more harshly than someone who is not Black. listen to how they are told to wear their hair. listen to which neighborhoods and circles they are welcome in and which they are excluded from. listen to someone try to talk black, but then turn on grammar police mode when a black person speaks in public or writes in a public forum. listen. then we might begin to understand cancel culture.
meet a Japanese-American neighbor and listen to how their parent or grandparent was forced to give up home and property and all their goods and be moved into an internment camp - here. in this country. sixty years ago. in this land of the free. and listen to how the anti-Japanese sentiment persisted long after the camps were closed. listen. then we might begin to understand cancel culture.
these are just a few examples of cultures that have truly been cancelled here in the United States. land of the {some are} free. home of the {many are more} brave {than anyone should ever have to be}.
before we (white people of European descent, many of us professing Christians) cry cancel culture, let's look at the words we are using and the situations we are talking about. sit with the words cancel culture. and think about what it would truly mean to have your culture cancelled. because ours hasn't been. and it's not in danger of being.
as for me, i want to amplify the cultures that have for so long been cancelled. there is so. very. much. we can learn.
.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..
sources for this besides my own thoughts: conversations on facebook yesterday, particularly with jeannine and annemarie and kelly, and also this article
photos: the tree skeletons are my own, the layered artwork was done by this friend - who at some point shared Acts 17:26 - God has made of one blood all the peoples of the earth - and these beautiful words continue to inform the way i see my relation to people - we are all of one blood, all made by one Creator.
.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..